Sunday, 1 December 2013

‘To defeat an incumbent President is no picnic, no tea party’

Guardian Logo

  • Written by Akpo Esajere

IT is a euphoric moment for the opposition. But while the wrapping up of merger (read regrouping by power seekers) imbues in politicians first flushes of success, the going is never too easy. Structures would have to be re-gigged. The question of who gets what will inevitably come up.
  Opposition politicians can be said to pull a good card last week when a group of seven (G-7) governors and their breakaway faction from the Peoples Democratic Party (PDP) joined the new kid on the block, All Progressives Congress (APC).
  It is a boost to the fledgling APC, no less the widening of the horizon for the party, registered only last July but already showing signs of emerging with more clout if it could fix obvious internal contradictions within its ranks. 
  One of the outstanding gains of last week’s merging is that the North (read core North) is virtually guaranteed the opportunity to field at least one strong candidate — and on a platform that is emerging as fast-growing in size and by 2015 could command considerable dynamism and political gusto to give the ruling PDP a run for its money.
  In effect, a decent try is being made to set up a credible arrangement whereby power at the centre, which had shifted from the North to the South for much of the last 14 years of uninterrupted government by elected people, could return to the North in 2015.
  Power had eluded the region with the demise of President Umaru Musa Yar’Adua, who died on May 5, 2010 after only two years and about 11 months into his first term in office. 
  This ushered in unexpected truncation of the rotation formula of the presidency between North and South, with which the PDP fought the 1999 presidential election. The far North, comprised of the 13 states of Northwest and Northeast, had felt short-changed since then.
  Fulfillment of the objective of the presidency returning to the North is the kernel desire of far North politicians, who fought hard for it but lost in the 2011 presidential election. They have been battling so hard again this time until it became clear to them that they could not outwit President Goodluck Jonathan in the PDP to have the party ticket or stop him from seeking to run for a second term in office.  
  That desire has been at the very root of the crisis that shook the PDP for most of the last one year. On the surface, the G-7 (actually, G-6; circumstances, probably beyond his control, pushed Governor Rotimi Chibuike Amaechi of Rivers State over the edge and into the fold), talked ceaselessly of anti-democratic practices, high-handedness, injustices, lack of fair play and such like in the ruling PDP.
  But since the PDP took over the reins of government, the party, a behemoth, which enjoys referring to itself as largest party in Africa, along with its rambling army of hardcore adherents and desperate power seekers, including the recent deserters, had thrived on showing healthy disdain and contempt for due process, thus foisting on the country a culture of impunity.
  President Jonathan would seem to be a beneficiary of that impunity: Before the PDP convention last year to pick party functionaries, northern politicians had given the game away in a shadow election in Bauchi by selecting Dr. Musa Babayo over Alhaji Bamanga Tukur, Jonathan’s candidate for party chairman. It was the beginning of hostilities, the first bullet fired in the battle to control the PDP headquarters in Abuja.
  Recall that Babayo was the party acting secretary under the acting chairmanship of Alhaji Kawu Baraje, the same chairman of the breakaway faction, who announced their merger with the APC last week. 
  Jonathan needed a trustworthy ally and mild-mannered Tukur, 88, businessman and politician, not in the mould of pro-northern campaigner like Professor Ango Abdullahi or for that matter Dr. Junaid Mohammed, suited the President perfectly.
  For added advantage, Tukur’s fourth wife, Mariam, is Ijaw like the president. Indeed, Erelu Bola Shagaya, a socialite, one of the wealthiest women in this country, is reputedly a close friend and confidant of Jonathan’s wife, Patience. Shagaya’s son, Sheriff, is married to Tukur’s daughter.
  And so, Tukur, backed by Jonathan has been weathering all the storms to keep the president’s second term hope alive. They not only took control of the party machinery, but using every means available, they also took the fight straight to the governors, who had become too powerful in the party to check them, particularly those identified as opposed to Jonathan running for second term.
  In about one year of Tukur’s chairmanship of the PDP, the party National Executive Committee (NEC), where the governors’ caucus is the haymaker, has not been called. Had he done so, they would simply have voted him out.  
APC and the Southwest
ANOTHER likely gain of last Tuesday’s marriage is the Southwest, a zone often found relapsing into what its critics like to ridicule it with as “playing cocoon politics” (interpreted to mean tribe/ethnic-based politics). 
  If all works out well for the APC mergers, the Southwest appears set for the first time to get more fully and actively involved in national politics, also called mainstream politics.
This is likely to be a campaign issue in the zone to be used against Jonathan’s (expected) bid for second term in office in the 2015 election.   
  Perceived marginalisation of the Southwest surfaced during the eight-year rule of former President Olusegun Obasanjo. Although the Yoruba were to gain symbolic comfort of being “in charge” at Abuja (centre), since his emergence was an assumed Yoruba presidential slot, the zone often complained of neglect; that Obasanjo could not point to any tangible thing it did for the Southwest.
  That complaining has now heightened to open grumbling against Jonathan, who is repeatedly accused of “total exclusion” of the Yoruba from the corridors of power in all three arms of government. To some, it is “perhaps unintended.” To others, it is “intended.”
  In any case, the APC, which is likely to retain its stronghold of the Southwest, and with the possibility of also executing a strong showing in the Northwest, could look forward with hope at 2015.
  Even so, the Southwest could come through as a battleground of sorts. While the zone would normally identify with progressive politics (also called “leftist” or “you think human rights” politics), the likelihood of the APC coming up with a northern presidential candidate, thus making 2015 a straight North-South contest, would task the zone.
  The age-old sophistication of voters in the zone is all too well-known. Also, the Southwest may have arrived at a crossroads where it is being called to get more actively involved in mainstream politics and could well be still asking itself how to go about it.  
APC and the presidential slot 
THE APC is a ready platform for a northern presidential candidate. That is all so obvious. It would be out of place for the Yoruba to push for the presidential slot soon after Obasanjo’s eight-year rule.
  Indeed, getting a northern ticket is believed to be the sole aim of the Hausa/Fulani community in teaming up with others for the initial merging that led to the APC. Last week’s entrants from the PDP can be said to enhance the party firepower. 
  But former Head of State and three-times presidential contestant, Gen. Muhammadu Buhari, a leading light of that move, whose moribund Congress for Progressive Change (CPC), along with the Ahmed Bola Tinubu-led Action Congress of Nigeria (ACN) essentially engineered the initial merger, makes them the principal leaders of the APC. How the PDP entrants will blend in the set-up deserves to be watched. 
  Politicians form political parties to run for elections. A memorandum of understanding (MOU) is being hammered. How the APC will eventually handle long-standing ambition of Buhari to be president remains an intriguing point. 
  He commands a cult followership in northern states, especially among the masses and the youths. With the latest addition of PDP former gladiators into APC, this might become a bit more complicated. The conduct of primaries to pick a presidential flagbearer may prove the litmus test for the APC.
  It is not clear how it will all jell with former Vice President Atiku Abubakar, a long-standing runner for the presidency. Right now, Atiku is keeping his next moves close to his chest, even while providing some muscles for the PDP breakaway group.
  He emerged from the shadow election organised by the Mallam Adamu Ciroma committee of northern elders to select a northern candidate for the 2011 presidential election but lost to Jonathan in the PDP primaries. Buhari, who ran then under his CPC, was himself defeated by Jonathan in the 2011 election.
  In some circles of the APC, the idea of coming up with “new bloods” and “doing away with old hands and their baggage” are being pushed around. Names such as Rabiu Kwankwaso, Aminu Tambuwal, Sanusi Lamido Sanusi are mentioned. 
  But whether any of these personalities could spring a strong enough rivalry against a possible Jonathan appearance in the race is a matter for contention in the party.
  In the midst of this, the recent registration of Peoples Democratic Movement (PDM), which Atiku had kept afloat and financed following the passing on of its founder, Gen. Shehu Musa Yar’Adua, is widely believed to be a stand-by strategy for him (Atiku) to have a platform to run in case he failed to make it again in the PDP and even in the APC.
  And so, there are speculations that Atiku has the option to talk with the APC or move his followers in the PDM to raise the hand of a northern candidate in the APC, to boost the chances of a chosen northern candidate. 
  In some political circles, it is said that both Atiku and Buhari could elect to withdraw backstage and be content with pooling forces with other northern elders to back a new breed northern presidential contestant. 
Some say Buhari could raise the hand of Kwankwaso in Kano. It would be interesting watching Buhari do so. 
  The Kano governor’s unpretentiously strong northern sentiments is said to endear him to many in the region, who see him as a good bet to take over from Buhari in the race for the presidency. Tambuwal, the House of Representatives Speaker, is also featuring in the undercurrents.
Jonathan versus his opponents
OF the seven aggrieved PDP governors and their faction moving or moved over to do business in the APC, at least three would be in no hurry to quit the PDP. Babangida Aliyu has said it was only proper to conclude peace talks with Jonathan before taking the next step. 
  The mercurial, smooth-talking two-term governor of Niger State and chairman of the Northern Governors’ Forum, in addition to being a member of G-7 and hitherto a strong campaigner for power to return to the North, has to soften somewhat, even as he continues to show his face among his protesting colleagues.
  Reports quoting unidentified senior officials of the Jonathan presidency tend to cast him in the mold of “the most unreliable of the lot” and sometimes “a traitor.” Last week, he left the meeting with the APC leaders before the splinter group chairman, Baraje, announced the merger with the APC. 
  Aliyu and his Jigawa State counterpart, Alhaji Sule Lamido, also a two-term governor and an influential actor within the PDP in the last 10 years, who was also not present at the APC/splinter group and merger announcement, are players with deep knowledge of political foot-shuffling.
  Although they had emerged as notable champions of the northern project to get the presidency to return to the North, both had also, at some points, been linked to posturing for the presidential ticket.
  Among older generation of PDP adherents, they are politicians with clout who had built a formidable following in their domain. They have name recognition and they will not be hasty in moving into uncharted territory or part of inconsequential arrangements with doubtful outcomes. 
  This may not necessarily have anything to do with their names being mentioned in connection with EFCC cases, although it is quite striking in terms of timing and manner their names spring up.
  In 2011, as Jonathan fought for the PDP ticket, Aliyu’s name suddenly came up at the EFCC only to die down. Recently, it came up again. 
  Lamido’s son was named in connection with alleged money laundering. Now, it is his two sons. But Lamido, a firebrand of the Aminu Kano school of talakawa politics, warned last week that he could not be blackmailed from pursuing any cause he chooses. 
  Aliyu, a former permanent secretary, is adept at caucus politics. At the FCT, Abuja, he moved close to former President Obasanjo, who took him and, more or less, imposed him on the Niger PDP in the 2007 elections, to outwit the then outgoing governor, Abdulkadir Kure, an Obasanjo critic, who once asserted that the former president had no right to choose his successor. Kure is now said to be working himself back into the good graces of the PDP as a strong supporter of Jonathan. 
  As for Amaechi and Murtala Nyako, not much can be said about them for now. Amaechi and Jonathan may find a way round their current acrimonious relationship. How that will happen, especially the forms it will take are, is, however, in the womb of the future. 
  Nyako and Atiku, both from Adamawa State, as well as Tukur, the PDP chairman, have all along pursued topsy-turvy relations, which present one portrait today and another tomorrow. How Nyako will fair in the current jostling cannot be described with precision. Safe to say that at the end of the day, he may not leave the PDP. Adamawa is a PDP state.
Enter the National Conference
UNLESS Jonathan decides to leave a lasting legacy, not much is likely to take place with the proposed National Conference. In any case, until perhaps 2019 if the President secures a second term in office, no serious work may be done. 
  Before February next when partisan campaign is expected to get into full throttle, the best that may be achieved is for the Senator Femi Okurounmu Presidential Advisory Committee to submit its report, on which basis the government may constitute the conference.
  By bringing the conference into the bargain, Jonathan has succeeded in dousing much of the tension that had engulfed his administration. When he inaugurates the body attention will shift there. 
  Alliances or new discussions are often had among delegates to the conference. In a sense, if delegates are constituted for the current conference, a good number of them could end up being campaigners for Jonathan’s second term bid in the 2015 presidential election. In sum, as one analyst put it: “to defeat an incumbent President is not a picnic; no tea party.”
  Over time, the PDP had emerged as an election-winning (some of its adherents even proudly call it “capturing”) machine. Before now, it seemed widely assumed that a runner at the polls is simply a done deal if it were on the platform. 
  And so, the party primaries were often the real scenes of electoral warfare, characterised by bribery, corruption, abuse of rules and guidelines, intrigues, bitter rivalries, fraud — everything both in the book and outside is put into capturing the ticket. 
  In the end, the party leadership would manage to negotiate its army of bitter fighters into some form of truce, which it cunningly calls “family affair.” 
  This time, however, the family broke up!

Africa's Crumbling Center

New York Times


Nairobi, Kenya — The Central African Republic is often called a forgotten country, but that isn’t quite right. It has had a long and substantial international presence and sizable foreign investment. It’s just that those efforts haven’t made much difference. As the country rapidly descends into greater violence, the difficult truth is that more — and much better — international and regional involvement is its only hope.
Opinion Twitter Logo.

Connect With Us on Twitter

For Op-Ed, follow@nytopinion and to hear from the editorial page editor, Andrew Rosenthal, follow@andyrNYT.

France has had an almost continuous military presence since the country gained independence in 1960, including the 400 soldiers deployed at the start of the current crisis. The European Union has a delegation in Bangui and has been the main donor for 10 years. United States Army personnel arrived in 2011 as part of efforts to capture Joseph Kony, the leader of the Lord’s Resistance Army, who has been indicted on war crimes charges by the International Criminal Court and is believed to be hiding somewhere in Central Africa.
The foreign presence is not limited to Western countries. South Africa had a bilateral military cooperation program from 2008 to 2012. Last March, 13 of its troops were killed attempting to keep President François Bozizé in power. The regional Economic Community of Central African States has maintained a peacekeeping force since 2008. Its 2,500 troops will soon come under the command of the African Union-led International Support Mission in the Central African Republic (Misca). Moreover, the United Nations has been working to rebuild the country since 2010.
The Central African Republic was supposed to be a test case for the latest thinking on how to deal with fragile states. Given all this political, military and development assistance, it is difficult to understand why the country is not only weak, but dissolving.
President Bozizé was ousted by a loose alliance of guerrilla fighters from throughout the region known as Seleka, which supported his successor, Michel Djotodia. In September, Mr. Djotodia, in a move that contributed to instability, disbanded Seleka. With no chain of command, the fighters descended into banditry and widespread violence. With no effective national army to challenge them, violent militias are now protecting some elements of the population and terrorizing others.
The spreading conflict has also taken on a religious dimension, with fighting between Muslims and Christians. The transitional authorities are weak and the modest African peacekeeping force is no deterrent against the militias, which includes mostly Muslim fighters.
After intervening successfully in Mali, France is preparing to salvage another of its former colonies, beginning with an additional 800 troops. Last Monday, the United Nations deputy secretary general, Jan Eliasson, asked the Security Council to reinforce the African Union-led mission and ultimately to transform it into a United Nations peacekeeping force. Discussions are underway on a new resolution. The United States has proposed a budget of $40 million.
But United Nations peacekeepers are not going to arrive any time soon and the situation in Bangui is fast deteriorating. With a prompt and robust mandate accompanied by effective funding, African and French troops might be able to pull the country back from the brink. But the key to ending the country’s nightmare will also lie in the ability of Africa, France and the United Nations to forge a well-coordinated strategic partnership to restore order and rebuild the institutions necessary to preserve order.
When the Security Council meets this week, it should beef up logistical support to the African-led peacekeepers and authorize France to use all necessary means to support that mission. The United States, along with the European Union, should move quickly to provide the necessary financial support.
At the same time, Africa’s leaders must step up to the plate and provide more support to the African Union. Stabilizing the Central African Republic will require a doubling of the proposed 3,600 Misca troops. Securing the capital will only be a beginning: This mission should also safeguard the main roads, starting with the major commercial artery running from Bangui to Garoua-Boulaï, at the Cameroonian border. This would both stabilize the Central African Republic and reduce the very real threat of violence spreading to its neighbors.
The Security Council has a precious opportunity to restore security. Without this, the task of implementing the transitional political road map cannot begin, there will be no reforms, elections expected in early 2016 will be difficult to convene, and the transition may stall and even collapse with only one result: civil war with unspeakable consequences for Africa’s volatile center.
Thibaud Lesueur is a Central Africa analyst for the International Crisis Group. Thierry Vircoulon is the group’s project director for Central Africa.

The gentle art of cracking passwords

Pet catIf you have a cat, or any other type of pet, do not use its name as part of a password

Related Stories

On the internet, the most popular colour is blue, at least when it comes to passwords.
If you are wondering why, it is largely because so many popular websites and services (Facebook, Twitter and Google to name but three) use the colour in their logo. That has a subtle impact on the choices people make when signing up and picking a word or phrase to form a supposedly super-secret password.
It's just one of the many quirks to be found in the password-picking habits of us humans. There are plenty of others. For example studies suggest red-haired women tend to choose the best passwords and men with bushy beards or unkempt hair, the worst.
These studies also reveal that when it comes to passwords, women prefer length and men diversity.
Big data
These facts have come to light thanks to the vast number of passwords that have been stolen from websites and online services, says security researcher Per Thorsheim.
Adobe, LinkedIn and game website RockYou have all been hit in breaches that involved the theft of login names and passwords. Add to this the steady drip of security breaches at other firms and you have a vast corpus of data that can shed light on what passwords people pick.
The number one conclusion from looking at that data - people are lousy at picking good passwords.
Computer chipBrute force attacks throw computer power at passwords
"You have to remember we are all human and we all make mistakes," says Mr Thorsheim.
In this sense, he says, a good password would be a phrase or combination of characters that has little or no connection to the person picking it. All too often, Mr Thorsheim adds, people use words or numbers intimately linked to them.
They use birthdays, wedding days, the names of siblings or children or pets. They use their house number, street name or pick on a favourite pop star.
This bias is most noticeable when it comes to the numbers people pick when told to choose a four digit pin. Analysis of their choices suggests that people drift towards a small subset of the 10,000 available. In some cases, up to 80% of choices come from just 100 different numbers.
People power
It is this realisation about human bias that has transformed the way that people, both the good guys and the bad, go about cracking passwords.
"Now brute forcing is absolutely the last tactic we would use," says Mr Thorsheim.
Brute forcing, as its name suggests, throws raw computer power at the problem of password cracking. Such an attack on a password would first try "a" and then work through all possible letter and number combinations before ending at "zzzzzzz".
Password security depended on computer power never getting to the point where billions of those sequential combinations could be tried in a reasonable amount of time. The mathematics (time multiplied by tries) defeated the crackers.
"But", says security researcher Yiannis Chrysanthou from KPMG, "it's not about mathematics any more because it's people that select the passwords."
Many security researchers look to improve their password cracking methods so they can advise companies about what they need to do to make people choose phrases that are more secure.

Cracking passwords

I tried to see how easy it is to crack passwords for myself.
Armed with a list of hashed passwords culled from one of the many sites where stolen lists are dumped every day, I looked for software that could crack them.
I turned to two of the best known, Hashcat and John The Ripper, loaded up my hashes, picked my word lists, applied my rules and let them rip.
Soon after I had a list of cracked passwords - not all of them - and I stopped the process before it had completed.
The words and phrases that emerged first were wearyingly familiar. It's no wonder that people's online accounts are regularly breached if so many are choosing obvious combinations such as "aaa123" as a password.
They also try to crack the passwords in the stolen lists to get a better idea of what people have been using. In such situations often what is being cracked is a sequence of letters known as a "hash".
These fixed-length strings of characters cannot be rewound to reveal what characters gave rise to them. However, because hashing algorithms work according to a fixed set of rules then "123456" will always produce the same seemingly random sequence of letters. Under the MD5 hashing system "123456" always produces the string: "e10adc3949ba59abbe56e057f20f883e".
Generate hashes for all the words in a long list related in one way or another to a target and there is a much better chance of guessing their password, says Mr Chrysanthou, who developed novel rules for cracking passwords while studying at Royal Holloway.
It was via this approach that he managed to crack the password: "Ph'nglui mglw'nafh Cthulhu R'lyeh wgah'nagl fhtagn".
At first glance this mangled collection of lower and upper case letters drizzled with apostrophes looks like it would be pretty secure. Unless you are a well-educated geek who knows it comes from a horror story written by HP Lovecraft.
Targeted attacks are likely to scour social media for words, names and dates important to a victim. Knowing the names of someone's children, pets, parents or street can help unpick a password very quickly.
Facebook on a phoneWhat you do and say on social media can give clues to your passwords
The bad guys try to crack passwords, says security researcher Bruce Marshall, because they too know another truth about people - they are lazy.
This means that there is a very good chance, 70% according to some studies, that a password associated with an email address on one site might well be used to log in on one or more other online services.
Many cyber-thieves target smaller sites to get at their lists of passwords and then try them in other places to see if they have been used.
"If a criminal is cracking passwords then most likely they gathered them from a specific site and are trying to gain access to additional accounts," says Mr Marshall.
The sheer number of passwords released to the web has created another problem, he says.
"If an attacker can't gain access to the targeted site's password database then they may resort to an online password guessing attack where they try common usernames, email addresses and password combinations," he says.
So, if you want to pick a stronger password do not use simple combinations of words and numbers, choose words that are only tangentially related to you and make sure the password you use for your online banking is used for nothing else.

More on This Story

Related Stories

Nigeria: The Oil Revenue Mystery

Vanguard (Lagos)

BY OBI NWAKANMA

OPINION
Governor Chibuike Rotimi Amechi has opened an important debate about Nigeria's oil industry, and it is an important question. How much oil does Nigeria sell daily? How much of this actually reflects in Nigeria's revenue accounts? This has been a mystery. Indeed Nigeria's oil revenue account is one of the most secret of mysteries, made even more so by a most secretive administration whose executive authority is so wide-ranging that it can afford to play God on this matter.
The Nigerian National Petroleum Corporation is run like a secret cult. It does not account to the public although the Act of parliament establishing it requires that it makes public Nigeria's oil account regularly. But for as long as Nigerians can remember, the NNPC has not published a verifiable true account of revenue earnings accruing to the government of Nigeria from oil and sundry sales.
The Ministry has been run like a personal fiefdom, and has generally made the issue of the records of oil sales a need-to-know, available perhaps only to the President. But oil is Nigeria's public resource. Its management is at the heart of Nigeria's economic life. It is from the sale of oil mostly that Nigeria's public expenditure depends. It is a strategic aspect of Nigeria's national political and economic life, and its management has to be accountable and transparent. But this is not so. In the eight years of Olusegun Obasanjo's presidency, after the transition from military tyranny, the federal government did not account to Nigerians about the quantity of oil sold nor about the true accruing revenue from oil. In those eight years, Nigeria's oil sales and production was placed under a hermetic seal.
There was an aura of deep and effulgent corruption emanating from that area of Nigerian life. In 1979, the Shagari government was forced by the public interest activism of the late Professor Ayodele Awojobi and Afrobeat musician Fela Anikulapo-Kuti to open up investigations into the alleged missing N2.8 billion by empanelling the Ayo Irikefe Commission of Inquiry. There was also the senate committee that investigated the loss of the money from Midland's Bank, and in the end, it came to nought. The alleged missing N2.8 billion happened under the watch of Muhammadu Buhari as Minister for oil and Olusegun Obasanjo as Head of the Military government. Nothing came of those inquiries.
The Irikefe Tribunal reports absolved the parties, but it left a lingering level of distrust in the minds of Nigerians about the management of Nigeria's oil resources. The lingering suspicion was given further oomph with the alleged misuse or misapplication of the oil "windfall" from the Gulf war in 1990 by the Babangida military administration for which Abacha set up the Okigbo panel.
The Okigbo reports clearly indicted the administration for the mismanagement of the revenue which in the words of the report was applied to mostly "non-regenerative investments." Various commentators on the Okigbo report of 1993 have continually missed the point of the report: its core grouse, or the basis of its indictment of the Babangida administration was in the misapplication or misadministration of the windfall, rather than in any express accusation of its loss. It was from that "windfall" for instance that the Babangida government bought the famous Mercedes Benz cars for the Supreme Court judges that became quite the subject of media scandal. In any case, I dwell on these past questions because the management of Nigeria's revenue particularly from oil on the federation account has been a serious point of contention in Nigeria. It is the monkey on the shoulders of Nigeria's federalism.
How much control the President has over the Federation account; how accountable the presidency is to the federating governments on the question of the national revenue account has often been the subject of serious contention within the context of Nigerian federalism. The problem is in the pool account - the so-called federation account and the various accounts that service it. Every financial year, the federal government sets the budget benchmark for oil sales.
Typically, they calculate the price for oil at a lower rate than is obtained in the market. While the federal government plans based on a specific revenue benchmark, the excess that comes from the sales is paid into an agreed account called the "Excess Crude Account." This account is serviced as part of the federation account belonging to the government of Nigeria - that is the federal, state and local governments, and to be disbursed according to the revenue sharing formula. There are two problems here: the separate oil account from excess crude sold is under the signatures of the Minister of Finance and the Minister of Petroleum. Nigerians live by faith, and whatever we are told by the Ministers of Finance and the Petroleum is gospel, no questions asked. Nigerians do not know exactly how much oil Nigeria sells.
The president has told Nigerians that various problems including crude theft and the current slide in the global oil market has resulted in a significant production shortfall. But skeptics are asking: how much in real barrels does Nigeria produce daily? Nobody knows this. It is shrouded in mystery and it leads to major disenchantments. Nigerians suspect that much more Nigerian oil is in the market than is currently accounted for. The second point raised by Chibuike Amechi in Sokoto at the NGF retreat is the possibility that the Jonathan government may have authorized, without regard for the governors and Nigerian people, the unaccounted use or withdrawal of $5billion from Nigeria's excess crude account. Amechi claims that as at January, the excess crude account stood at $9billion, but currently stands at $4billion.
"We don't know who took the $5billion." Amechi should know because as governor of Rivers state and chairman of the NGF, even if now its factional group, he has access to the financial intelligence that ought to matter to the state. His allegation cannot be easily dismissed as baseless. The minister for Finance, Dr. Okonjo-Iweala has of course refuted any loss of money from the excess crude account, but she quite frankly sounds unconvincing, and so again we need to ask: is money missing from the excess crude account, minister? Nigerians should ask this question about this money until we get a full picture.
The National Assembly as the chief purser of the nation must initiate an inquiry into this affair and into the general question of the management of Nigeria's major nest egg and the health of the goose that lays those golden eggs. It is time we had greater oversight over the petroleum ministry and over the running of Nigeria's financial affairs.

Nigeria: Investigation - How NYSC Extorts Billions of Naira From Corps Members

Premium Times (Abuja)

BY AMINA MOHAMMED

When some corps members serving in Nasarawa state turned up for a meeting at the Lafia local government secretariat on Wednesday, June 19, most of them were prepared for a showdown with authorities of the National Youth Service Corps, NYSC.
Shortly after they gathered outside the NYSC zonal office, they had received an annoying notice of yet another mandatory levy which would be deducted from that month's allowances.
The NYSC coordinator in the council area had told the furious corps members that they were required, mandatorily, to contribute yet another part of their allowance to fund the building of an office for the NYSC in the area.
The corps members in Nasarawa were enraged by the notice because earlier in the year, in February, they had been extorted of N500 each for the same project.
They are among the over one hundred thousand graduates that struggle through the NYSC scheme annually, with parts of their meagre allowances pilfered by officials of the NYSC, a government body established in 1973, to inculcate the culture of service, volunteerism and national unity into young graduates.
Although the corps was established to manage the welfare of graduates serving the scheme, it has ironically developed micro strategies to plunder corps members or aid other individuals and corporate bodies do same.
Usually, most of the pilfering schemes are designed as voluntary contribution, but the actual implementation does not allow free will to choose not to donate.
Corps members are threatened and cajoled to pay up. Defaulting corps members are sometimes punished with denial/delay of monthly allowance or extension of service year.
NYSC Foundation Slush fund
The National Youth Service Corps Foundation (NYSC Foundation), a non-governmental organization (NGO) established by ex-corps members in 1998, is one of the most sophisticated schemes used to plunder corps members.
The NYSC Foundation said it exists to reduce unemployment by empowering ex-corps members. It has ex-director generals and staff of the NYSC as its board members and directors.
The Industrial Energy Company Ltd in association with Industrial and General Insurance Plc, IGI, initiated the formation of the NYSC Foundation.
Since 1998, the foundation has collected hundreds of millions in Naira from corps members, with the help of the NYSC; in a scheme both institutions are not willing to share records with the public.
At the end of every service-year cycle, graduating NYSC members are forced to pay a membership fee of at least N500 to join NYSC Foundation. In return, they get a paper ID and a promise to receive a loan for a small or medium enterprise. Defaulters are punished with denial of allowance, and in some cases, extension of service year.
But only few members get the loan. The bulk of the money is never accounted for.
On the IDs issued the graduating corps members, the foundation admits that over 100,000 Nigerian graduates pass through the NYSC scheme annually. The foundation virtually extorts at least N50 million annually from its forced new members but has neither a public record of contributors nor annual statement of accounts to members.
After more than a decade of existence, the foundation announced its first soft loans to 43 ex-corps members in 2010. The members received amounts up to N250, 000 (total of less than N11 million) to establish personal business like hair salons and recharge card kiosks.
The foundation gave out the loans after receiving at least N600 million from graduating corps members in its first 12 years.
Three years later, in 2013, they announced secret loan amounts to 93 members of the foundation.
The foundation also claimed it renovates NYSC camps, but refused PREMIUM TIMES' investigators access to its account records.
"I cannot give you a detailed amount of corps members that have contributed to the NYSC Foundation because it's a voluntary donation and not a compulsory one," the spokesperson of the Foundation, Aliyushlate Ise, told PREMIUM TIMES at the foundation's Abuja office.
Did you see me there?
When confronted with evidence the payments are usually made compulsory, he asked: "Was I the one that collected money from you? Did you see me there?"
Actually, the NYSC Foundation does not go to the field to collect money. NYSC Foundation is run by top Nigerian business moguls and civil servants. Remi Olowude, the Executive Vice Chairman of multimillion Naira insurance company, IGI, is the founding Chairman of NYSC Foundation. The Foundation maintains a small office at the IGI house in Abuja.
The NYSC does the actual money collection on behalf of the foundation. Corps members are made to pay the money during their final clearance before passing out. The payment is part of the criteria that must be met by corps members before they are cleared to conclude their service year. Remittances are then made to the foundation by the NYSC.
The NYSC also refused to disclose its monetary transactions with the foundation to PREMIUM TIMES. The corps rebuffed months of repeated enquiries and disregarded our FOI request for information. Critics believe that top officials of the NYSC are among beneficiaries of the loot the foundation earns annually from graduation corps members.
Denials
The NYSC denies it does compel corp members to make mandatory payments to the NYSC foundation. The NYSC foundation also denies forcing members to pay. But accounts from past members of the service indicate the NYSC facilitates the payment of dues to NYSC foundations through coercive measures.
"During my time, I was forced to pay N500 in return for an NYSC Foundation membership card," Isa Yakubu, who served in Abia state in 2007 said. "We were threatened that our last allowee (allowance) would be seized if we did not comply."
"I paid during my time," Idowu Johnson, who served in Bauchi in 2005, said. "It is a small money. When you consider the consequences of not paying, you will just pay and let it go."
Just like Messrs Yakubu and Johnson, many other exiting corps members, eager to conclude their service year and collect their discharge certificates, promptly obey the directive and make the N500 payment.
Almost all are not bordered about how the money is spent. "Nobody wants to know what they do with the money. All of us just paid so as not to have any trouble," said Olaitan Abeni who completed her youth service in Abuja in 2013.
The big question
In addition to the grand NYSC Foundation fraud, there are other micro-pilfering schemes developed by officials of the NYSC at the grassroots to extort members of the corps.
Despite their meagre income, corps members are forced by NYSC officials to pay for various sundry charges purportedly meant for funding projects ranging from buying magazines to running local offices, and like in Nasarawa, building offices.
The NYSC is fully funded by the government, and corps members in Nasarawa are not letting the extortions pass. They have petitioned the National Human Rights Commission seeking to stop the NYSC officials.
"The big question is; is it corps members' responsibility to build NYSC offices in Nigeria? Are corps members supposed to use their monthly stipend to execute NYSC owned project? ... who is responsible for building local government NYSC offices in Nigeria?" the protesting corps members asked in their petition to the human rights commission.
Many of the petitioners have, however, concluded their service year while others wait on the human rights commission to treat the petition.
Nathaniel Ibwari, one of the corps members said that at least 10 percent of his total earning from the NYSC scheme was extorted by officials of the corps before he concluded his service in October.
"I am calling on the authorities concerned to look into this matter and act fast in order to stop this blatant extortion or corruption," he said.


How teenagers, desperate couples fuel baby factories

Vanguard News - Latest updates from Nigeria, including business, politics, entertainment, fashion, health, technology, naija lifestyle

By KINGSLEY OMONOBI – Abuja

Baby factories where teens are kept and made to bear children for a  token and the babies  sold  have become the order of the day. As shocking, immoral and  unreligious as it may seem, some Nigerians still  indulge in the act. In this interview, Force Public Relations Officer, CSP Frank Mba, speaks on what the police are doing to check  the trend.
There have, of late,  been an increase  in  cases of baby factories as discovered by the police, especially in the South-east. What do you think is responsible for the development?
An exposition of the concept of baby factories tells us the cause of this ugly trade. Baby factories are locations where young ladies or girls, some teenagers or little above that, are harboured and deliberately encouraged or forced to become pregnant and subsequently give up their babies for sale. The fact that these ladies are from poverty-stricken background makes it possible for them to be easily enticed with the offer of monetary gains by the operators of these illegal baby farms. After paying some token to these young mothers, the babies are  sold to buyers for illegal adoptions.

baby-factory-new
Can you throw more light on the cause of this problem?

As earlier stated, one of the major factors that fuel the crime is the pecuniary benefit associated with it. This is further fueled by the patronage the operators enjoy from desperate couples who have, in their wrong belief, reduced marriage to mere baby making unions. You can imagine that,
in some cases, the prices of these babies differ in sex and occasionally in complexion.
Baby boys are costlier because, in this part of the world, some wrongly believe that having baby boys gives the woman legitimacy and strong hold on her marriage. Other factors that fuel the crime are greed and ungodliness which are the common traits of those in this unwholesome practice. We can also add that illiteracy and ignorance on the part of the teenage victims who are either deceived or given false promises or even expressly forced into baby-making homes, play significant roles here.

As a law enforcement agency, what strategies have the police put in place to control the  ugly trend?

Our strategies are two pronged. First is through core law enforcement strategies and secondly through non-traditional law enforcement approach. Law enforcement strategies in this case include intelligence gathering, raiding of suspected baby factories as well as arresting and prosecuting the operators and their clients. In doing this, we adopt another a  strategy which I can call  ‘naming and shaming’. In this case, suspects are exposed to  the public through the publication of their pictures and stories. This sometimes serves as a disincentive to those still indulging in the unwholesome practice.

What about the second strategy which you said is non-traditional law enforcement approach?

The non-traditional approach  is through public education and enlightenment, just as we are doing now through  this interview and also through counseling of victims who are mostly under-age girls. It must also be stated that we are constantly training and re-training our men on how to improve on their capacity to handle the crime of this nature. In addition, the IGP is also making efforts at strengthening our special branches, including Juvenile Welfare Centres (JWC) and Anti-Human Trafficking Unit that handle cases of child trafficking and such other exploitation of women and children.

Are there laws against baby farming?

Yes. Firstly, the exploitation of these girls for such purpose is against their fundamental human rights. Secondly, it offends the anti-human trafficking laws and other related statutes. Thirdly, it is against the Child Rights Act because some of these women are under-age who are incapable of taking their own decisions.  It is also amounts to another form of slavery which was  banned decades ago. Abduction of young girls and child theft are offences under our  laws.

Can we say that this practice has  negative image on our society?

Indeed there are negative implications of this crime. It gives us negative perceptions and soils our image in other climes. Just recently, the EU published a report saying human trafficking is the third biggest crime in Nigeria. It also increases prostitution and spread of infections. Some of the young girls, in an attempt to overcome the psychological trauma associated with giving up or selling their babies, resort to taking dangerous drugs including psychoactive or psychotropic substances like marijuana and other depressants. This could have long term negative implications for our polity.

Is there anything  government can do to stem the trend?

Government can contribute in several ways to control this, through the strengthening of our adoption laws and putting machineries in place to monitor compliance to standards in the approved motherless babies’ homes. This is  necessary because some of these homes are  filthy for human existence while some have veered off from being such homes to baby-breeding factories. On the other hand, government may take steps to subsidize fertility treatment such as  assisted  reproductive technology (ART), including in vitro fertilization (IVF) to help couples in need, address the problem of infertility and recurrent pregnancy loss. This will help reduce the quest for ready-made babies.

How do we prevent this recurring problem?

To prevent this crime, parents must totally embrace their responsibilities to their children. This cannot be divorced from the proper education of the child. Again, couples must also
realize, through effective reorientations, that marriage goes beyond just being a baby-making union; they must come to terms with this reality to avoid the wild desperation to have a child at all costs. We must also stop stigmatizing  young girls for having ‘illegitimate’ pregnancies. The truth is that most of these girls run into these baby factories in an attempt to seek protection from parental or family chastisement and indeed the associated stigma arising from such ‘unwanted’ teenage pregnancies.

How lecturers underdeveloped the universities (3)

Vanguard News - Latest updates from Nigeria, including business, politics, entertainment, fashion, health, technology, naija lifestyle

By  Douglas Anele

However, and this is the crux of the matter, those responsible for running the universities on daily basis have, through financial rascality, misused available financial resources. Wastages and corruption in the system are legion. They include explosive increase in the purchase of official cars, frequent unnecessary trips by top management of universities many of whom are senior academics, huge allowances and gifts for members of university councils, lavish convocation ceremonies, overpriced contracts awarded to relatives, friends and cronies of VIPs in various campuses most of which are poorly executed, and so on.
I am sure that many senior academics at different levels of authority will have serious cases to answer if the federal and state governments undertake thorough independent audit of the entire financial transactions of universities. Hence, although our political leaders deserve opprobrium for neglecting the universities and wasting available resources on self-aggrandisement, sometimes criticism of government for not providing basic facilities in our institutions of higher learning is misplaced because highly placed lecturers in positions of authority oftentimes misappropriate available funds. Meanwhile ASUU leaders and activists insist that government must provide everything universities need to function, even relatively inexpensive items these institutions, through imaginative financial management, can comfortably provide for themselves. In this connection, any university that does not have good classrooms, decent toilets for both staff and students, markers and dusters for lecturers, fairly good library and basic equipment like Bunsen burners for laboratory work ought not to have been licensed to operate by the NUC in the first instance. Approving half-baked universities just because of the explosion in the number of candidates seeking university admission is a waste of time, money and human resources.
asuu1
Yet, NUC continues to approve such universities, with the active connivance of senior academics and Professors for whom “anything goes” as long as their financial demands are met. Now, instead of Vice Chancellors wasting money on things of tangential value, such as creating new directorates, lavish convocation ceremonies and purchase of vehicles among others, they should use such funds to provide affordable items for teaching and learning. It is pertinent to observe that, in virtually all universities transparent accountability with respect to funds for capital projects and money derived from internally generated revenue is lacking. For a change, ASUU should be demanding from university authorities across the country proper accountability with respect to the subventions from government for capital expenditure, instead of blaming government all the time for petty items like Bunsen burners, toilets, fans etc. It is well known that the new buildings and facilities in various campuses are below the standard established in the years from 1962 to around 1990, which is a reflection of unimaginative planning and lack of Platonic aesthetic sensibility amongst university authorities.

This is corroborated by the fact that buildings constructed in Nigerian universities from around the 1990s, supervised by senior academics in the relevant departments as consultants, are ghettoes compared to the world class structures built before that time at the University of Lagos, such as UNILAG library, faculty of engineering building, the Senate Building the Council Chambers, Main Auditorium, etc.
Another problem is the ethnicisation of key positions in the universities, and I will use appointment of Vice Chancellors to illustrate the point. Ideally, by its mandate, a university is supposed to be universalistic in orientation since its mission consists in the pursuit of knowledge of The True, The Good and The Beautiful. This implies that merit, excellence, and proven record of performance must be the decisive factors in the selection of candidates for the elevated position of VC. Nevertheless, for a sizeable percentage of lecturers the most important factor is the ethnic origin of a potential VC; the question of merit and competence is secondary.
On several occasions, lecturers from a particular ethnic group where a university is located insist that a “son of the soil” must be the VC or else they will make things extremely difficult for any non-indigene who has the audacity to take up the post. It is a measure of increasing indulgent narrow-minded provincialism in the academia that virtually all VCs in our universities hail from the culture area where the institutions are located.
Once upon a time, when Nigerian universities were truly Ivory Towers, the Vice Chancellors of the Universities of Ibadan, Lagos, and Nigeria, Nsukka, hailed from the same ethnic group, and from my research, they performed well. Why must the VC of UNN be an Igbo? Must the VC of Obafemi Awolowo University, Ile-Ife, be a Yoruba? I am not aware of any principled stance of ASUU against the ethnicisation of Vice Chancellorship in our universities, which is unfortunate because that position is critical in the proper day-to-day management of universities, and ethnicity is neither a necessary nor sufficient criterion for selecting the most qualified candidate for the job.
Anyway, Nigerian academics in general have retreated into the cocoon of ethnic parochialism, because it provides many of them a strong platform for negotiating and competing effectively in the system to make up for deficiencies in cognitive and emotional intelligence as well as in character.
Even in the recruitment and promotion of lecturers, several heads of departments, deans of faculties, provosts of colleges and VCs have consistently sacrificed merit on the altar of ethnicity. Students even allege that some lecturers give preferential treatment to students from their ethnic group while grading examination scripts, tests and take home assignments. To summarise: the proclivity of an increasing number of lecturers to put ethnic considerations before merit and capacity to perform is a dangerous trend that has impacted negatively on our universities; colleagues should begin to think seriously about how to discourage the practice. Lecturers are mainly responsible for the skewed procedure and requirements for promotion of academics, which allows square pegs to be in round holes in our universities.
Now, the criteria for advancement from one cadre to another are set by academics with the approval of university councils. I maintain that the system is inadequate because it places too much emphasis on journal publications, especially foreign ones, and neglects quality of teaching. Many truant lecturers with poor teaching skills have successfully exploited the weaknesses in the system and became Professors either by cloning and plagiarising works written by others (including graduate students), publishing in non-existent or very obscure journals or by recycling the same set of ideas in different publication outlets.
Indeed, some desperate colleagues connive with unscrupulous individuals outside Nigeria to float phantom journals just for attaining the professorial rank after which the so-called journal will sink into oblivion. Of course, some lecturers neglect teaching, and concentrate on publishing half-baked and badly argued ideas in order to be “high flyers” in the system. I just cannot understand why ASUU has never worked to ensure that a good system for students’ evaluation of lecturers’ performance is instituted in universities as one of the factors that determine the career movement of lecturers.
TO BE CONTINUED