Monday, 9 March 2015

2015 GENERAL ELECTIONS: FACTUAL ANALYSES AND MY ENDORSEMENT (19)



Temple Chima Ubochi
ubochit@hotmail.de
Bonn, Germany

If you put a federal government in charge of the Sahara Desert, in 5 years there'd be a shortage of sand (Milton Friedman)Just as a poetic discussion of the weather is not meteorology, so an issuance of moral pronouncements or political creeds about the economy is not economics. Economics is a study of cause-and-effect relationships in an economy (Thomas Sowell)
It is no crime to be ignorant of economics, which is, after all, a specialized discipline and one that most people consider to be a 'dismal science.' But it is totally irresponsible to have a loud and vociferous opinion on economic subjects while remaining in this state of ignorance (Murray N. Rothbard)
ome Yoruba leaders, such as Otunba Gani Adams, while acknowledging that the South West is a place that you cannot use the media to deceive, think that the national conference was one of the best achievements of Jonathan since he became the president of this country in 2011. Those south-west leaders, and many others from other zones, have implicit faith in President Jonathan's ability to turn Nigeria around, because, according to them, those who are saying that Jonathan does not merit second term are those who are eager to take over power from him. For people like Otunba Adams, if Jonathan can survive with the presence of Boko Haram, the attack from MEND at the beginning of the government, and in 2009, the economic meltdown, and at the end of the day, our GDP is the first in Africa, definitely if we can have him in second term without much problem, he can do more than we expected. Otunba Adams sees President Jonathan as a detribalized president who does not have the mind of tyranny.

 In his words: "He is the only president that people will abuse and he will not ask the security agents to arrest and try you. What members of the opposition did to Jonathan and he absorbed it, they could not have done10 percent of it to former President Olusegun Obasanjo when he was in power. His simplicity cannot be compared, his humility is something to write for others to emulate. So, he is a president that can build a strong foundation for Nigeria's nascent democracy. I believe he merits a second term. People are blaming Jonathan for the hardship in the country. Why can't they blame state governors and lawmakers who are being given constituency allowances? When I talk about politicians I speak without exception. Many governors and local government chairmen cannot give account of what they collect every month from the allocation account. Before the current fall in the prices of crude oil, some were collecting about N6-7 billion every month and all they do is to embark on elitist projects that have no direct impact on the lives of common people, only to come and accuse Mr. President that he is not performing. One thing I respect Jonathan for is despite pressures from the ruling Peoples' Democratic Party (PDP), he refused to influence the result of elections as we have witnessed from the result of Anambra, Edo, Ekiti, Ondo and Osun states governorship elections. We were surprised when a large number of security agents were sent to Ekiti and Osun states during the last elections; it was later we got to know that some members of the party gave him a wrong assessment of the situation that there would be crisis during the elections".

Buhari is yet to tell Nigerians his economic plan for Nigeria, if he wins the election. One can safely say that Buhari has no economic plan for Nigeria. All we hear from him is only piecemeal, archaic and unrealistic; he's yet to tell us how he plans to achieve anything for Nigeria. Buhari is only over-emphasizing the tackling of corruption and insurgency, without giving us any meaningful plan for the economy. He seems to have no idea how the economy works, as he was asked what he will do if he wins the election, since there is a drop in oil price. Buhari answered that the first thing he will do is to "stabilize the oil price". Imagine that? So, Buhari doesn't know that there is nothing he can do about the oil price, as it is the international market forces that influence the prices of oil? Market forces, upon which the price of oil hangs, are independent of countries' vagaries of politics, and Buhari doesn't know that. So, how can he rule Nigeria, when as a former head of state, he still lacks a rudimentary knowledge of political economy? Only an international political or power or economic bloc, through its actions, and there must be a reason for that, can influence the prices of oil, as was the case during the Arab-Israeli war of 1973, when the Arab oil producers boycotted oil export, that made Nigeria to export more oil, well above its quota, thereby making so much money then. 

That was the time Gowon, as the head of state, made the infamous statement that Nigeria has so much money and doesn't know how to spend it. Gowon then went on to offset other countries' debts and financial obligations, when he could have invested it in the industrialization of Nigeria. Gowon could have built more refineries, more universities and technological institutes then (lack of economic foresight).
For those who don't know: The 1973 oil crisis began in October 1973, when the members of the Organization of Arab Petroleum Exporting Countries (OAPEC, consisting of the Arab members of the OPEC plus Egypt, Syria and Tunisia) proclaimed an oil embargo. By the end of the embargo in March 1974, the price of oil had risen from $3 per barrel to nearly $12. 

The oil crisis, or "shock", had many short-term and long-term effects on global politics and the global economy. It was later called the "first oil shock". HistoryNet Magazine (January 16, 2014) narrated that "The October 1973 War had begun. Before it was over, battalions of tanks, hundreds of aircraft, and legions of soldiers would clash in one of the late 20th-century's most momentous wars. Oil prices would soar to unprecedented heights, and the specter of nuclear war would loom over the battlefield. Though brief-fighting ended within a month-the conflict had enormous impact. It broke a political stalemate and made possible a long Egyptian-Israeli peace that's unique in the roiling Middle East. The roots of the fighting in 1973 lay in the Six-Day War of June 1967, when the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) trounced combined Arab armies and took the Golan Heights from Syria, the Sinai Peninsula from Egypt, and East Jerusalem from Jordan".

Office of the Historian, Bureau of Public Affairs, United States Department of State (Last modified on October 31, 2013) reported that During the 1973 Arab-Israeli War, Arab members of the Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC) imposed an embargo against the United States in retaliation for the U.S. decision to re-supply the Israeli military and to gain leverage in the post-war peace negotiations. Arab OPEC members also extended the embargo to other countries that supported Israel including the Netherlands, Portugal, and South Africa. The embargo both banned petroleum exports to the targeted nations and introduced cuts in oil production. The onset of the embargo contributed to an upward spiral in oil prices with global implications. The price of oil per barrel first doubled, then quadrupled, imposing skyrocketing costs on consumers and structural challenges to the stability of whole national economies. 

Since the embargo coincided with a devaluation of the dollar, a global recession seemed imminent. U.S. allies in Europe and Japan had stockpiled oil supplies, and thereby secured for themselves a short-term cushion, but the long-term possibility of high oil prices and recession precipitated a rift within the Atlantic Alliance. European nations and Japan found themselves in the uncomfortable position of needing U.S. assistance to secure energy sources, even as they sought to disassociate themselves from U.S. Middle East policy. The United States, which faced a growing dependence on oil consumption and dwindling domestic reserves, found itself more reliant on imported oil than ever before, having to negotiate an end to the embargo under harsh domestic economic circumstances that served to diminish its international leverage. To complicate matters, the embargo's organizers linked its end to successful U.S. efforts to bring about peace between Israel and its Arab neighbors".

Chika Onyeani (The African Sun Times, NY) wrote that "All Nigerians have heard from Buhari since he accepted the presidential candidacy of the APC is how he is going to fight corruption. But Nigeria faces problems other than corruption, which, no doubt, is important to the welfare of good governance. Every Nigerian leader has pledged to fight corruption; every world leader has pledged to fight corruption. There is corruption everywhere in the world, but what is very important is how you are going to lift the standards of life of the average Nigerian. Right now, oil price, the main stay of the Nigerian economy, has fallen to its lowest level. The Naira is depreciating fast. Nigerians are yet to hear what Buhari is going to do with less money coming into the country. 

Promising Nigerians a pie in the sky is not what is needed now. What is needed are specific policies spelt out to address the issues of the economy, but issues of security. How are you going to deal effectively with the Boko Haram insurgency if in the past you have been an enabler of the group through your indiscreet utterances?" Segun Olanipekun also wrote that "The third problem facing Buhari's campaign team is the lack of a well-articulated policy document on how to identify and proffer solutions to Nigeria's myriad problems. Often, what are churned out by members of his campaign team are copious excerpts from the manifesto of the APC which in itself is not a bad idea. But a serious contender needs to go further by drawing up a distinct policy framework of his own vision, though embedded in the ideological spectrum of his party, as an indication of his preparedness to solve priority problems facing the nation that is presently enmeshed in disorder and chaos. Perhaps, to fill this gap, the Buhari team has turned his acclaimed zeal to end corruption into a boring campaign refrain, always recalling his 'no-nonsense' war-against indiscipline (WAI) to cow the population when he was a military head of state between 1983 and 1985.

But the Buhari team should be reminded that this is a different political climate demanding dexterity and not decrees. A democratic, 21st Nigeria definitely should have no place for such ancient governance template. It would have been more relevant if Nigerians are told about his plans to waddle through the complex and complicated political waters of Nigeria. No one from his team, not even Buhari himself, has clearly and succinctly given good answer to this recurring issue. By now and from experience, Buhari ought to know that putting forward a well-defined, thoughtful and comprehensive policy programme on such issues as infrastructure, power; unemployment, corruption, insecurity and numerous others, is a demand of serious leadership. Such a document has to be Buhari's contract with Nigeria. So, the Buhari campaign has not done well in the third crucial political campaign game called social contract with the Nigerian people!"

To point out that Buhari is an economic neophyte who knows nothing about Nigeria's economic history or records, and a person who has no economic plan for Nigeria, and can't run an economy, if he wins the election, he failed to get his record accurate when he lied in Kaduna recently. There, he said: "On the issue of unemployment, you in Kaduna are aware of the many industries that used to be here. We used to have companies like the Nigerian airways, the Nigerian Railway and others, but since the PDP came to power 16 years ago, these companies have collapsed."

Someone pointed it out to Buhari that he lied here, by reminding him that:
"In 1983, before General Buhari overthrew the Shagari democratically elected government, Nigeria Airways Ltd has a fleet of about 30 aircrafts!
As at 1986, barely one year after General Buhari was overthrown from power, Nigerian Airways had accumulated debts that far outstripped its revenues and had a dismal staff-aircraft ratio of 500-1!!!

By 1988, cost cutting measures led to the discontinuation of flights to a number of African destinations including Cotonou, Dakar, Douala, Kinshasa, Monrovia and Nairobi!
At the end of military rule in 1998, after being plagued by mismanagement, corruption and over-staffing, Nigeria Airways had incurred debts of more than $60m, a poor safety record and only one single aircraft flying domestic routes and two leased aircrafts.
How about the Nigerian Railways?
Nigerian Railway Corporation declared bankruptcy in 1988!
In 2002, passenger services were discontinued altogether!
In 2006, plans were made to restore the rail lines and add new locomotives.
In 2012, under President Jonathan, scheduled passenger service was restored on the Lagos - Kano route

In December 2014, again under President Jonathan, scheduled passenger services was also restored on the Port Harcourt - Enugu route which terminates in Maiduguri!..this is not all! The coastal railway project is about to begin. The Abuja Kaduna Fast rail route is about to begin".
What we have heard from Candidate Buhari so far is bogus economic policies or plans hedged round with lies and incompatible facts and figures.

Read more:

To be continued!

TIT BITS
THE THANX IS ALL YOURS!!!


Sunday, 8 March 2015

Deconstructing Buharimania

Vanguard News - Latest updates from Nigeria, including business, politics, entertainment, fashion, health, technology, naija lifestyle

Douglas Anele
Politics, according to cynics, is a dirty game.  Many Nigerians tend to accept thatnegative characterisation of politics and politicking without question. However, in my view, Aristotle’s depiction of politics as the endeavour  for the noblest of human beings is nearer  the truth  than the cynical standpoint. Briefly defined, politics is the authoritative allocation of power to make decisions and implement them within a geopolitical space.
BuhariChat
In both  democratic and aristocratic or authoritarian systems,  a tiny minority or group  exercises political power by determining  the nature and structure of governance for the vast majority of the population. Therefore, since political institutions evolved mainly to promote the well-being of members of the society over whom  political authority  is exercised,  it is extremely important to create transparent processes for selecting the noblest  of minds for political office.
Unfortunately, human beings  have not invented  foolproof  reliable  method  whichwould guarantee that the best  individuals  would always emerge  as leaders. Indeed, perfect  implementation  of the  recommendations  by Plato and other political philosophers cannot occlude the possibility  that  political power  might be  in the hands of  men and women of inferior  intellectual, emotional, and moralquality.
The impossibility of creating perfect socio-political  institutions that can guarantee that only the most suitable would occupy political offices entails  that individuals should channel their creative energies towards constructingdemocratic institutions  in their respective countries  capable of minimising  therepercussions  of bad leadership. According to the Austrian-born British philosopher, Karl Popper, this is achievable only  through periodic elections.
Democracy is not an ideal political system,  but it is preferable to other arrangements  because it allows members of the society to play some role in selecting those that would lead them for a specified  period.  Like other non-authoritarian countries, Nigeria is  still trying to create a viable democraticprocess  appropriate  for her  historical experiences and  developmental needs.
Of course, the 2015 elections are crucial  in this respect  because,  if conducted successfully,  that would go a long way to consolidate  the modest progress made since 1999. On the other hand, if politicians derail the  process because of inordinate desperation for power, it would be another disappointing case of “hope deferred.”
The  presidential contest  between the two frontrunners,  Dr.  Goodluck  EbeleJonathan and  Gen.  Muhammadu  Buhari, has brought to the fore once again the perennial problem of selecting  political leaders in a  fledgling  democracy. The All Progressives Congress (APC) on whose platform  Gen.  Buhari  is contesting has  mounted  vuvuzela-sounding  campaigns  with the sole purpose of dislodging the ruling  Peoples  Democratic Party (PDP) from power.
In fact, the heat and tension  from APC  was  so palpable that many Nigerians became too pessimistic and apprehensive about  what would happen next.  Despite the unnecessary threats by  Gen.  Buhari  and his cohorts, the presidential and gubernatorial elections have been postponed; tension has gone down  somewhat, although there is still a sense of foreboding  because of  ferocious  propaganda  by the  majortwo  parties.
A  disturbing product  of the vociferous APC campaign machine is  Buharimania, that is,  worshipful support  bothering on religious and cultic excitement  forBuhari  by a section of the Nigerian population especially in the North,  coupled with  fanatic belief that APC  can deliver positive change in  the country  if  Buhariwins the election. It would take a lengthy treatise drawing on the resources of psychology, sociology and contemporary Nigerian political history to explain in details the provenance of  Buharimania.
It  must be pointed out,  however,  that  Buharimania  is a phenomenon rooted in  devotion to  and  uncritical preference for  a retired military dictator with a reputation for rigidity, integrity and honestyover  a well-educated, humble and methodical democrat  with an easygoingdisposition  towards governance.  The danger here is that wily APC kingpins can exploit it to foment trouble if the  party loses the elections.  Understandably, the propaganda machine of APC  deliberately suppresses President Jonathan’s achievements by  continuously  denigrating his administration.
It projects  Gen. Buhari  as the  only presidential candidate with the  capacity to eliminate corruption, mount a decisive fight against insecurity, and promote economic development.  In addition, the  party has been working hard to minimise the collateral political damage that Gen.  Buhari’s  image as an inflexible, not so well educated, ageing military dictator  with  outdated  understanding of  economic management  might cause it in the general  elections.
Now, because the  full positive  impacts  of  the modest achievements  by  President Jonathan are yet to  be felt  nationwide, it appears that the message of  “change”  from  APC is resonating with the masses.  But a closer look at the antecedents of APC leaders  reveals that the gospel of change is fundamentally unrealisable and illusory, a desperate attempt to exploit the hopes, aspirations and anxieties of Nigerians to wrest the highest political office from  the ruling party.
Unscrupulous conservative politicians who benefitted immeasurably from the corrupt system they helped to create and impose on Nigerians dominate the top echelons of the party. In order to substantiate my claim, I will  embark on  a systematic  deconstruction of Buharimania  and  APC’s desperate quest for power. My main argument is that the  party,  as presently constituted and managed,  cannot deliver sustainable meaningful change  to  Nigerians.
For starters, consider the major figures in APC. The arrowhead of the party  is Gen.  Buhari, who pledged in 2011 never to contest for any political office after the election held that year. Now the question  is:  why did the retired general renege on  that  promise, especially considering his hyperbolic reputation as a  man who keeps his word? Was  the change of mind  motivated by strong desire to get even with President Jonathan who defeated him in the 2011 presidential election or  was it necessitated  by messianic delusion about being the only one capable of addressing the hydra-headed problems facing the country presently? Why did he succumb to the opportunistic persuaders desperate for political survival and relevance at all cost?
In my opinion, Gen. Buhari’s  decision to contest again and failure to mentor a younger  and better-educated  politician to  political prominence as his successor after losing  the  presidential election  thrice are indicative of a man obsessively preoccupied with power. Bola  Tinubu’s  argument that Gen.  Buhari  had to  be drafted into  the presidential election because countries at crossroads in the past  were rescued from perdition by  their army  generals is, to put it mildly, ludicrous and historically inaccurate. Moreover,  in Africa particularly, military intervention in politics has had a detrimental effect on the economic and socio-political development of several countries, to the extent that coup d’états are detested everywhere.
Therefore, it is plainly unrealistic to believe that  seventy-three years old Gen.  Buhari  who three decades ago presided over the most draconian military regime in Nigerian history has suddenly  completely  mutated  into an  apostle of democratic change.   APC chieftains know that old habits die hard, and that  it is harder still for a conservative Muslim and former soldier like Gen.  Buhari  to change so dramatically. Keep in mind that one of the reasons Gen. Ibrahim  Babangida  gave for overthrowing Gen.  Buhari  was that the latter was too rigid and opinionated to preside over a multiply plural country like Nigeria.  Thus,  I am not sure that  APC’s  presidential candidate has developed the degree of emotional intelligence required to navigate successfully the treacherous landscape of Nigerian politics.
Several kingpins of APC have held, and are still holding  various  public offices.Yet there is  very little to show that the era of “business as usual” has ended. For instance, in APC controlled states, the problems of bloated cabinet, overconcentration of development in the urban centres to the detriment of the rural areas, emasculation of local governments, cronyism, and financial rascality are still rampant.
Meanwhile, a  sizeable number of prominent APC members were formerly in PDP.  It  would be surprising if Nigerians have not recognised yet  the  hypocrisy  in  chieftains of  APC  welcoming  enthusiastically  renegades from the very party they have been disparaging and criticising for years.Perhaps,  Tinubu  and others  are too desperate for power and would do anything to get it, and  their  criticisms of PDP  might stem from  jealousy towards a party that has dominated the political space since 1999. Whatever might be  the case,frankly  there is  very little  to show that APC can be trusted as the vehicle of positive change in the country  if its candidates win the elections.  To be continued.







MUST READ





Frankly Speaking

Nigeria Today

Moment to Moment

  • NNSM 2011 finalists

    Hare so fast

    The hare is a mammal, it is bigger than the rabbit and not known for its depth or intelligence....
    Read More →


The Orbit

Sunday Perspectives

Outside looking in